Scenario planning is a way of creating alternative, plausible scenarios, based on a range of factors. In turn, scenario planning can help users to assess strategy against a range of plausible alternative futures, with the scenarios created providing a context to help managers make reasoned decisions.
Also known as
- Scenario thinking.
- Scenario analysis.
The purpose of Rose, Bud, Thorn is to help you:
- Recognise both strengths and weaknesses so you can put in place measures to do more of what’s going well and fix problems.
- Encourage ideation and debate within teams. Discussing Buds can encourage the development of new, innovative ideas.
- Gather insight and learn from all members of the team, even, or especially, those who may be reluctant to share.
The Rose, Bud, and Thorn offer three prompts around which you can frame your thoughts or discussion, as shown in the following table.
Why use it
When to use it
Rose, Bud, Thorn can be used in a wide range of situations. It can be used individually or in a group. It can, for example, be used as a check-in exercise at the start of a meeting, a tool to encourage self-reflection, or as a discussion tool.
How to use it
- Divide what you know into:
- Things you know something about. These are likely to be trends, representing continuity and momentum.
- Elements considered to be uncertain or unknowable. These require you to speculate and to create alternative scenarios.
- Create scenarios by bringing your areas of knowledge and uncertainty together. One way to present your scenarios is to write them as though you are in the future, looking backwards at what has happened.
When you are creating your scenarios, you should bear in mind:
- There is no single method for creating scenarios. Therefore, the techniques used by different people may be inconsistent, unclear and ‘woolly’.
- There is no single method for converting scenarios into decisions.
- Scenario design is subjective rather than objective.
- There is frequently weak integration between scenario planning and other planning mechanisms.
- There is a tendency among users to want to choose only one scenario and to try to predict the future, rather than entertaining multiple futures.
- There is a tendency for users to see their chosen scenario as fixed. However, users need to be flexible, able and willing to adapt to updated information and changing circumstances.
- Scenario planning can provide an alternative to trend-based approaches, which assume that the trends of the past will extend unchanged into the future. The creation of multiple futures that can help organisations to prepare for different situations. In this way, scenario planning may be a useful tool to help manage risk.
- There is little documented evidence of the effectiveness of scenario planning.
- Because you are dealing with unknowns, it is hard to determine how valid the scenarios that you create are.
Use in conjunction with
- Improvement Service. (nd) Scenario Planning Toolkit: Step 1- Identify Driving Forces. Available at: https://www.improvementservice.org.uk/about-us/covid-19-support-for-councils/scenario-planning-toolkit/step-1-identify-driving-forces (Accessed: 6 December 2023).